03-05-2013, 07:48 AM
I am neither a weapons or munitions expert, but having followed the gist of this thread, it appears to me that (wittingly or otherwise) Guardsman has attempted to engage the group at large in the classic cycle of "Bring me a Rock" development. For those who are not aware, it is a request that is lacking either specification or requirement, and goes something along the lines of:
“Revise this,” they say.
“What am I missing?” we ask.
“It doesn’t quite address the issues,” they answer. “When it’s right, I’ll know it.”
That said, I have to completely agree with Bill, Joe, et al, and suggest that the game ends until someone can put some real requirements together, and ask for real solutions, and not speculation on what might satisfy an undefined problem.
“Revise this,” they say.
“What am I missing?” we ask.
“It doesn’t quite address the issues,” they answer. “When it’s right, I’ll know it.”
That said, I have to completely agree with Bill, Joe, et al, and suggest that the game ends until someone can put some real requirements together, and ask for real solutions, and not speculation on what might satisfy an undefined problem.