Who will ask to see the Form 1 or Form 4?

[Jake TN]

It will be interesting for sure. This case is not as simple as the EPA case or trump bum stock ban. Technically speaking the ATF did not have the authority to say whether braces would be legal or not. It was based upon their interpretation of the law. Instead of seeking clarification for the legislature, they approved the first brace, however, none of the preceding braces. Since they have taken so long to take action they are going to find themselves in a pickle. A crafty attorney would argue that they did not have the authority to approve the first brace and therefore everything is technically not legal (would open up lawsuits). On the flip side the Supreme Court could use that so many are in population that it is now common. This is a difficult case and will be interesting to see how it plays out. I am glad the Supreme Court is finally putting the different branches of government in their correct places. Personally I do not agree that SBRs or suppressor's should be NFA items, but that was passed by our legislative branch. Not sure much much weight Ex Post Facto . They are not charging purchase after the fact, but possession of an item.

This is likely more of a political decision to appeal to some of the more woke base and try to get the current classified material out of the news cycle. Personally, I think it will be overturned. Good time to go the courts to set the precedence for all other cases.