Reportedly a Deal is Done

[grayfox]

The only thing I would add here is the term "recidivism." The tendency to fall back into criminal acts.
If however, some period of time elapses and they "stay clean," then I would be ok with restoring some or all of the rights.
Some criminal types, ie, sexual and other predators, don't tend to reform. In cases like those, actually some kind of 3-strikes=life without parole, would be ok by me. Or, as you say, a (permanent) visit to another realm.