6.5 Grendel Forum
Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Printable Version

+- 6.5 Grendel Forum (https://65grendel.com)
+-- Forum: 6.5 GRENDEL DISCUSSION FORUMS (https://65grendel.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: 6.5 Grendel Ammunition & Reloading (https://65grendel.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: Looking for a New Electronic Scale (/showthread.php?tid=20721)

Pages: 1 2 3


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 02-29-2020

I’ve already got a box full of the best “Cheap” scales off amazon. Cool

And have tried several mechanical reloading scales, RCBS, Lyman, Hornady, etc..........they work and are decent back ups but are too slow for me to use on regular basis.

Edited: using a Chargemaster Lite now, and it’s adequate for bulk reloading but I want more precision and am looking more of a dedicated “lab” quality scale, not one of the powder dispensing scale from Hornady, RCBS, Franford, etc.......

So, I want to be able to bypass the auto-shutof and turn it on/off when I say so! Rolleyes

I want dual power source ac/dc.

I want to the hundredths of a grain resolution, at the minimum.

And most importantly, I want consistent, repeatable accuracy, quality.

I’d like to stay below $500 but, I could also be persuaded to go higher if there is a quantum leap in accuracy and usability.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - A5BLASTER - 02-29-2020

Chargmaster lite is going to be the best in your price range.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 02-29-2020

A5BLASTER Wrote:Chargmaster lite is going to be the best in your price range.

Yep Thanks but that’s what I have now but, it only has 1/10 grain resolution. Big Grin

Looking for more of a “Lab” type scale, not an actual powder dispensing scale. I just edited the OP for more clarity.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - centerfire - 02-29-2020

Harpoon1 Wrote:Yep Thanks but that’s what I have now but, it only has 1/10 grain resolution. Big Grin

Looking for more of a “Lab” type scale, not an actual powder dispensing scale. I just edited the OP for more clarity.

The resolution of the scale isn't what increases it's cost. Your Chargemaster is resolving to the hundredth, it just isn't displaying it. The CM uses a load cell as do some lower end lab scales; load cells lack the necessary rise time to measure trickled weights in the time and resolution you're asking for. Load cells can be made to work but you'll spend a lot of time waiting for it to resolve and then have a significant overthrow occurrence. CW, and similar scale/thrower combos mitigate some of the slow time and overthrow occurrence by reducing resolution (they're still slow).

As far as lab scales go, I think the FX120i (magnetic force restoration scale) is widely considered the go-to for high end scales for reloading applications. You can hand trickle onto it or upgrade to an Auto Trickler V3. The scale is below your $500 maximum (use "CAMBRIDGE" to drop the price to $465).

https://ceproducts.shop/collections/current-offerings/products/fx-120i-reloading-scale-122g-x-0-001g

Your other option is a Sartorius Entris 64, they are considerably more expensive, resolve to a unnecessary level (+/-.002), and have less aftermarket support.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 02-29-2020

centerfire Wrote:The resolution of the scale isn't what increases it's cost. Your Chargemaster is resolving to the hundredth, it just isn't displaying it. The CM uses a load cell as do some lower end lab scales; load cells lack the necessary rise time to measure trickled weights in the time and resolution you're asking for. Load cells can be made to work but you'll spend a lot of time waiting for it to resolve and then have a significant overthrow occurrence. CW, and similar scale/thrower combos mitigate some of the slow time and overthrow occurrence by reducing resolution (they're still slow).

As far as lab scales go, I think the FX120i (magnetic force restoration scale) is widely considered the go-to for high end scales for reloading applications. You can hand trickle onto it or upgrade to an Auto Trickler V3. The scale is below your $500 maximum (use "CAMBRIDGE" to drop the price to $465).

https://ceproducts.shop/collections/current-offerings/products/fx-120i-reloading-scale-122g-x-0-001g

Your other option is a Sartorius Entris 64, they are considerably more expensive, resolve to a unnecessary level (+/-.002), and have less aftermarket support.

That’s perfect, thanks. I was going to go with the FX120i if I couldn’t find anything worthwhile below $500. Your discount makes it a no brainer! Thanks again.Big Grin


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - jasper2408 - 02-29-2020

Keep in mind you have to have a 100 gram or 50 gram weight to calibrate that scale if you don't already have one. It doesn't come with a calibration weight. The scale comes set for 100 grams but you can change it to 50 grams. They sell the calibration weights on the same web site as the scale at a pretty good price. I forgot to order the weight when I ordered the scale so I got mine off of Amazon.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - FLshooter - 03-01-2020

You can get a Sartorious M prove digital scale for around $350. it’s it has a resolution of 1/100 g. But I think it’s overkill.My buddy has a high dollar digital lab scale and I do just as well as him with my Chargemaster and rangemaster 750 scales. A difference of 1/10 of a grain is fine.Trying to fine tune it 1/100 of a grain is overkill!
A while back Klem posted about using a ac power source for the charge master which I’m sure will also work with your chargemaster lite. Mine works with a 12 V motorcycle battery that I purchased from Walmart for around $40 . Stays charged for weeks and it’s easy to recharge with a battery charger .
Just make sure you get the polarities right or you will fry your chargemaster.Check it with a continuity gauge ,the middle is positive.
Isolating your scale from vibrations and other things like fluorescent lights helps too.And I re zero mine every 10 charges or so.Ever since I did this I have gotten my average velocity reading of 5 groups a lot closer. +/- 10. I’d like to get it +/- 5 but that may be a stretch. Anyway my groups are a little more consistent.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 03-01-2020

jasper2408 Wrote:Keep in mind you have to have a 100 gram or 50 gram weight to calibrate that scale if you don't already have one. It doesn't come with a calibration weight. The scale comes set for 100 grams but you can change it to 50 grams. They sell the calibration weights on the same web site as the scale at a pretty good price. I forgot to order the weight when I ordered the scale so I got mine off of Amazon.

Ok, planned on using the Chargemaster calibration weights, 2x50g, is that cool?


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 03-01-2020

FLshooter Wrote:You can get a Sartorious M prove digital scale for around $350. it’s it has a resolution of 1/100 g. But I think it’s overkill.My buddy has a high dollar digital lab scale and I do just as well as him with my Chargemaster and rangemaster 750 scales. A difference of 1/10 of a grain is fine.Trying to fine tune it 1/100 of a grain is overkill!
A while back Klem posted about using a ac power source for the charge master which I’m sure will also work with your chargemaster lite. Mine works with a 12 V motorcycle battery that I purchased from Walmart for around $40 . Stays charged for weeks and it’s easy to recharge with a battery charger .
Just make sure you get the polarities right or you will fry your chargemaster.Check it with a continuity gauge ,the middle is positive.
Isolating your scale from vibrations and other things like fluorescent lights helps too.And I re zero mine every 10 charges or so.Ever since I did this I have gotten my average velocity reading of 5 groups a lot closer. +/- 10. I’d like to get it +/- 5 but that may be a stretch. Anyway my groups are a little more consistent.

Well, I agree a 1/10 is perfectly fine, maybe even desirable, once you’ve located a node. I’ve got a Creedmoor load now that litterally .5 of a grain either high or low makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. Using Varget with a Sierra 130 GameChangers. Crazy stable.

And 1/10 resolution is one thing with a 80-100 grain 338 Lapua charge and another with a 8-10 grain 17 Hornet charge. Context and percentage of deviation matters.

I’m just NOT seeing that much “plateauing”, if any, using the Chargemaster now and the Satterlee method and smaller charges. Hard to separate the pressure nodes from the usual noise of 1/10 resolution. At least for me it is. Of course this is with 17 Hornet, 223, Grendel size charge weights. I’m hoping, being more precise with the FX120i will make those plateaus a little more obvious. And speed up my load development, which should help offset the cost of the scale!


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - FLshooter - 03-01-2020

Harpoon, Since you already own a charge master, you should try using a 12v dc power source.It is much more stable than AC power. It’s a cheap upgrade. And I think you’ll notice a difference.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - grayfox - 03-01-2020

Needing Electricity stability (DC vs AC) is primarily a function of the voltage quality from your supplier, plus any EMF distortions your own home equipt might introduce locally. In my years in the Electric industry I have not seen any appreciable charge distortions due to the electrical input; naturally any smoothing out you can do is better but even a battery supply will not completely isolate "airborne" EMF interference from stuff in/around your home. Example if you are in the basement the startup or shutdown of your furnace fan motor will throw plenty of static interference your way. If your scale is near to the cabling in the wall and you run flourescents then the static will filter over to the scale from the cabling. A person is certainly free to pursue voltage purity, if you will, but I am skeptical as to how much it will really do for you.
Also, a comment on the 0.01 gr resolution capability. In medium caliber rifles a 0.1 gr delta powder charge might cause an MV difference of 5-7 ft/sec, which is generally inside of a lot of the SD's people shoot with (precision usually needs +/- 2 SD to say you're within 95% probability of your next shot being at the desired MV value). Only when you have or seek MV stabilities like SD's of 2-3 ft/s, will a 0.1 gr difference be observable. Personally I could see some value in getting a +/- 0.05 gr resolution, but don't see a value in +/- 0.01.
The biggest keys I've seen in using any electronic scale are keeping static-producing motors/lights etc away from it, keeping it at a constant AC air temperature, keeping level and stable- vibration free, eliminating drafts and allowing sufficient warmup before use. And a consistent procedure for weighing loads and using the scale.

I'm not trying to knock OP for wanting to get more precise but just adding some cautions, that you might not get the bang for your buck that you're seeking.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 03-01-2020

FLshooter Wrote:Harpoon, Since you already own a charge master, you should try using a 12v dc power source.It is much more stable than AC power. It’s a cheap upgrade. And I think you’ll notice a difference.

Roger that, I’ll look into it.

Thanks.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 03-01-2020

Quote:............ In medium caliber rifles a 0.1 gr delta powder charge might cause an MV difference of 5-7 ft/sec, which is generally inside of a lot of the SD's people shoot with (precision usually needs +/- 2 SD to say you're within 95% probability of your next shot being at the desired MV value).............

Exactly. And when your doing a 0.2 grn Satterlee load test, that 5-7 Ft/sec per 0.1 delta can be a big deal when trying to interpret the data!

Well, if nothing else, once the FX120i gets here, I’ll be able to better verify the variation in the loads being dropped from the ChargeMaster Lite. If the deltas turn out to be inconsequential, I’ll just sell it and move on.

The rest of your post was informative and appreciated.

Thanks.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - centerfire - 03-01-2020

Harpoon1 Wrote:That’s perfect, thanks. I was going to go with the FX120i if I couldn’t find anything worthwhile below $500. Your discount makes it a no brainer! Thanks again.Big Grin

Once you have the FX120i and use it a bit take a look at the Auto Trickler V3. My A2520 Grendel load dispenses +/-.02gr in less than 10 seconds. I ran the same load in my buddies CM Lite and it took 28 seconds. Larger grain powder like H4831 take a little longer (maybe 15 seconds tops). I've owned a bunch of different scales and throwers and FX120i with ATv3 is amazing. A friend has a Prometheus and it works about the same for something like six times the price. You're going to love the scale regardless of the resolution, the advantages will be readily apparent.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - A5BLASTER - 03-01-2020

centerfire Wrote:Once you have the FX120i and use it a bit take a look at the Auto Trickler V3. My A2520 Grendel load dispenses +/-.02gr in less than 10 seconds. I ran the same load in my buddies CM Lite and it took 28 seconds. Larger grain powder like H4831 take a little longer (maybe 15 seconds tops). I've owned a bunch of different scales and throwers and FX120i with ATv3 is amazing. A friend has a Prometheus and it works about the same for something like six times the price. You're going to love the scale regardless of the resolution, the advantages will be readily apparent.

When did loading presision rifle rounds become a race?

If your worried about how long it takes too get the charge thrown. Your worried about the wrong things.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - Harpoon1 - 03-01-2020

A5BLASTER Wrote:When did loading presision rifle rounds become a race?

If your worried about how long it takes too get the charge thrown. Your worried about the wrong things.

Personally, I don’t like reloading, it’s just a necessary evil. Load development is the only part that is remotely interesting. Once Ive cracked the code, then you just become an assembly line worker. I’ll be 60 in a few days and time is more valuable to me now than money. I’ve got a bunch of other things I’d rather be doing instead of making ammo. If people enjoy it, more power to you. If I could buy ammo that was as consistently accurate as my reloads, I would never reload another round. Cool


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - nuthead - 03-01-2020

When I looked into it years ago I found the gempro 250 was the cheapest set of lab scales I could find... I settled on that and have been using it ever since


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - centerfire - 03-01-2020

A5BLASTER Wrote:When did loading presision rifle rounds become a race?

If your worried about how long it takes too get the charge thrown. Your worried about the wrong things.

Workflow. You can stand there waiting for your thrower if you want, your choice. I have things to do and somewhere between a four day travel week and family I need to load ammo, do development, live fire, compete, and have fun. I loaded just shy of 18k rounds last year (mostly pistol on a 650), starting in October I reduced my precision rifle ammo loading time by half with the ATv3. If you look through some other forums you'll find guys that use two CM's to keep the thrower from bottlenecking their workflow. This year I am scheduled to shoot multiple level 2 and 3 matches, host multiple trainers, and take more than one class at TR.

For anyone that is interested, SH and Accurateshooter have multiple threads running on the FX120i and the ATv3.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - centerfire - 03-01-2020

Harpoon1 Wrote:Personally, I don’t like reloading, it’s just a necessary evil. Load development is the only part that is remotely interesting. Once Ive cracked the code, then you just become an assembly line worker. I’ll be 60 in a few days and time is more valuable to me now than money. I’ve got a bunch of other things I’d rather be doing instead of making ammo. If people enjoy it, more power to you. If I could buy ammo that was as consistently accurate as my reloads, I would never reload another round. Cool

Prime is getting close, I still have some 6CM 115gr RDF I bought from them that I use to warm up with. Since I'm already using LRP Peterson brass I can shoot their ammo and put the brass into my once fired pile.


Looking for a New Electronic Scale - A5BLASTER - 03-01-2020

centerfire Wrote:Workflow. You can stand there waiting for your thrower if you want, your choice. I have things to do and somewhere between a four day travel week and family I need to load ammo, do development, live fire, compete, and have fun. I loaded just shy of 18k rounds last year (mostly pistol on a 650), starting in October I reduced my precision rifle ammo loading time by half with the ATv3. If you look through some other forums you'll find guys that use two CM's to keep the thrower from bottlenecking their workflow. This year I am scheduled to shoot multiple level 2 and 3 matches, host multiple trainers, and take more than one class at TR.

For anyone that is interested, SH and Accurateshooter have multiple threads running on the FX120i and the ATv3.

Lmao. Dude I have loaded nearly that much since November on my chargemaster lite. Since I have got it, i have loaded and fired enough rounds to burn out 3 AA 16 inch light barrels from my stash of 12.

Don't for one second try to convince yourself are anyone one else. That because you bought a 1600 dollar powder throw that it's saving you any great amount of time for other things.

Let's just cut the mud right quick on that fact.

Like I said if your more worried about the time it takes too get a charge thrown, your worried about the wrong things and should probably step away from the bench and reevaluate.

Now I'm all for more precision and one day when my chargemaster lite gives up the ghost I will have the autotrickler setup.